Forensic investigators combed over McArthur’s two-bedroom apartment for months, removing 1,800 pieces of evidence and photographing every square inch. They erected tents and used heaters to thaw the frozen ground. Police issued a plea to anyone who might have used McArthur’s services, and deployed cadaver dogs to multiple locations across Toronto. The planters were located outside a modest home, on Mallory Crescent in the Leaside area of the city, where McArthur had been employed as a gardener. McArthur was charged with the murder of Andrew Kinsman, 49, who had gone missing shortly after Pride Day on 26 June 2017, and Selim Esen, 44, who was reported missing about two months earlier.Īs a particularly cold winter dragged on into February, the city was horrified as police began to unearth the remains of corpses buried inside more than a dozen decorative planters. Inside, they found his companion already tied to the bed.
They ascended to McArthur’s 19th-floor apartment and broke down the door. The surveillance officers had instructions to arrest him if they saw him alone with someone else. McArthur had been placed under 24-hour police watch the previous day.
